Server Maker vs AiGuild
Updated
Server Maker (servermaker.xyz) is one of the most installed bots for building a Discord server with AI: 28.7K servers on top.gg. AiGuild does the same job at the start, then stays to run the server. Here are the differences, taken from their public pages.
In short
Both turn one sentence into a complete Discord server. Pick Server Maker if backups, cloning and styling matter most: weekly auto-backups on the free plan, and one subscription covers all your servers. Pick AiGuild if the server then has to run itself: AI answers tickets, and /ai sets up welcome, levels, giveaways and AutoMod in one sentence, in 7 languages, from €3.99 a month.
Choose AiGuild if
Your server has to live after it is built. AI answers your members' tickets, /ai sets up welcome, levels, giveaways, button roles and AutoMod protection from one sentence, and your server can join the directory to receive members. Everything works in seven languages, and the paid plan starts at €3.99 a month.
Choose them if Server Maker
You mainly want to protect or copy a structure. Server Maker takes automatic backups even on the free plan, clones an entire server, recolors roles and channels in one go and syncs bans across linked servers. One subscription covers all your servers, and its top.gg community is bigger than ours.
What Server Maker does better
- Automatic backups on the free plan: weekly, then daily with Maker+ ($4.99).
- Server cloning: structure and settings with Maker+, messages, bans and history with Maker++.
- One-click styling: color themes for roles and aesthetic symbols for channel names.
- Ban sync across linked servers, and structure lock (/structure).
- A bigger top.gg community: 28.7K servers against 27.7K, and about three times more votes this month (3.12K vs 1.15K on 4 November).
What AiGuild does better
- AI ticket replies: the AI writes the first answer from what it knows about your server.
- /ai sets the bot up in plain language: “run a Nitro giveaway on Friday” or “add a levels system” is enough.
- “Keep what's already there” is on by default on a server with content: nothing is deleted, with a backup and rollback.
- Seven languages for both the website and the bot: English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, German, Japanese, Polish.
- A public server directory with votes and rankings, to bring members in.
Which one to pick, by need
| Your need | Best pick |
|---|---|
| Back up or clone an existing server | Server Maker |
| Recolor roles and channels in one go | Server Maker |
| Several servers on one subscription | Server Maker |
| Tickets answered by AI | AiGuild |
| Set up welcome, levels, giveaways with one sentence | AiGuild |
| A non-English-speaking community | AiGuild |
| A bot with your own name and avatar | AiGuild (Premium) |
The bot's systems, on the free plan
| Feature | AiGuild | Server Maker |
|---|---|---|
| Set up in plain language (/ai) | Yes | Partly |
| Tickets with AI replies | Yes | Not stated |
| Tickets | Yes | Yes |
| Giveaways | Yes | Not stated |
| Levels and XP | Yes | Not stated |
| Reaction / button roles | Yes | Not stated |
| Automatic moderation | Yes | Yes |
| Welcome messages | Yes | Yes |
| Invite tracking | Yes | Not stated |
| AI server generation | Yes | Yes |
Server Maker: systems as described on its /features and /docs pages. Its Premium page sells credits, backups, cloning and speed, not these systems. Levels, giveaways, reaction roles and invite tracking are not mentioned anywhere on its site.
Feature by feature
| Feature | AiGuild | Server Maker |
|---|---|---|
| AI generation | Yes | Yes |
| Applies straight to the server | Yes | Yes |
| Editing afterwards | Yes | Yes |
| Bot under your own name | Yes | Partly |
| Community templates | Yes | Yes |
| Server directory | Yes | No |
| European hosting | Yes | Not stated |
| Interface languages | 7 | Not stated |
| Ratings and adoption | 4.85/5 on top.gg (233 reviews) · 27.7K servers | 4.8/5 on top.gg (223 reviews) · 28.7K servers |
The plans
AiGuild
- Gratuit0 €
- VIP3,99 €
- VIP annuel23,88 €
- Premium7,99 €
- Premium annuel47,88 €
Server Maker
- Maker Starter0 $
- Maker+4,99 $
- Maker++14,99 $
The same starting point
On Server Maker, /build ai creates roles, channels, categories and permissions from a description, with a preview to confirm; /edit ai and the Revamper then rework the server. On AiGuild, you generate on the website or with /ai in Discord, review the structure, then apply it. Both can roll back a change.
Prices, checked on 4 November 2026
Server Maker, paid through Patreon: Maker Starter is free (100 AI credits a month, 5 more per top.gg vote, weekly backups), Maker+ is $4.99 a month (1,500 credits, daily backups, structure cloning), Maker++ is $14.99 a month (6,000 credits, full cloning with messages and bans, no Server Maker branding). The price covers your account, not a single server.
AiGuild: free (10 credits every two weeks, a generation costs 5, plus credits for every top.gg vote), VIP at €3.99 a month, Premium at €7.99 a month, or €23.88 and €47.88 a year. You can also unlock a single server for €1.99 with no subscription. The two tools do not count credits in the same unit, so comparing credit numbers would be meaningless.
What happens to your existing server
This is the question to ask before applying anything. On Server Maker, the full build preview shows “Wiping existing structure…”, the Revamper preview warns that the action “cannot be undone”, and cloning offers overwrite or append. Time-based rollback (/revert, 30 days) is tagged Premium in their docs.
On AiGuild, on a server that already has content, “Keep what's already there” is on by default: the new structure is added alongside, with nothing deleted and permissions untouched. A full replacement only happens if you choose it, after an automatic backup, and rollback stays available.
After the build
Server Maker has a real management base: tickets with transcripts, welcome with auto-role, verification, logging, anti-raid and moderation (/moderate), all from the /maker dashboard.
AiGuild adds what Server Maker does not describe: levels and XP, giveaways, button roles, invite tracking, voice counters, and AI that answers tickets. Each system is set up with /ai in one sentence, for 1 to 5 credits.
AiGuild, for real
Three screenshots of the product as it is today (example server, no real data), taken from our press kit.
Common questions
Is Server Maker free?
Yes, its Maker Starter plan is free: 100 AI credits a month, 5 more credits per top.gg vote and weekly backups. Maker+ costs $4.99 and Maker++ $14.99 a month (checked on 4 November 2026).
Is AiGuild a good Server Maker alternative?
Yes if you want the same bot to run the server after it is built: tickets with AI replies, levels, giveaways, welcome and protection set up with /ai, in seven languages. If your need is backing up or cloning a server, Server Maker is still better at that.
Which one wipes my existing server?
AiGuild keeps everything by default on a server that already has content, with a backup and rollback. On Server Maker, the full build preview announces that the existing structure is wiped; cloning offers overwrite or append.
Which is better rated on top.gg?
They are neck and neck: AiGuild 4.85/5 (233 reviews), Server Maker 4.8/5 (223 reviews), checked on 4 November 2026. Server Maker is on slightly more servers (28.7K vs 27.7K) and gets more votes.
Can I use both?
Yes. Both bots act on your Discord server, which stays yours: nothing stops you keeping Server Maker for backups and adding AiGuild for tickets and /ai.
No credit card.